• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

The Professor Is In

Guidance for all things PhD: Graduate School, Job Market and Careers

  • Home
  • Courses & Webinars
    • How To …
    • The Art of the Academic Cover Letter
    • The Art of the Article
    • Unstuck: The Art of Productivity
    • On Demand Courses
    • Upcoming Live Webinars
    • Free Productivity Webinars
    • Gift Certificates
  • Personalized Job App Help
    • Document Editing
    • Quick Reviews
    • Specials
    • Interview Prep
    • Personal Negotiating Assistance
    • One on One Career Consults
    • Testimonials
    • Interview Testimonials
    • Graduate School Application Assistance
  • The Professor Is /Out/
    • It’s OK to Quit
    • Our Art of Leaving Program
    • Prof Is OUT Services
    • Our Prof Is OUT Team
    • Prof is OUT Client Testimonials
    • Ex-Academics: A TPIO Support Community
  • Workshops
  • Coaching
    • Pre-Tenure Coaching Group
    • Leaving Academia Coaching Group
  • Blog
  • Podcast

Toxic Hope

By Karen Kelsky | December 10, 2021

This story was shared by a reader recently. They have given me permission to share it here anonymously. Rarely have I seen the sickness of the PhD apparatus so clearly articulated. “Toxic hope” is another way of saying Berlant’s “cruel optimism” (2011), “when something you desire is actually an obstacle to your flourishing.” And in 2021, it has surely moved beyond cruel to toxic. Why do faculty still behave like this?  Is this not a kind of evil?

 


At my PhD graduation ceremony in 2018, the departmental speaker (a tenured prof) proudly listed all the jobs English grads, including the PhDs, were getting post-graduation. Not one of them related to the field directly. I recall the line “Our graduates go on to become yoga instructors, butchers, or to retrain in tech,” but it was much longer than that.

While this might seem like he was voicing a mistimed indictment of a field that has not successfully prepared students to market their skills for a world in which faculty jobs are ever scarcer, he meant it as uncritical praise. “How adaptable the degree, and our graduates with it!”

I kept thinking about how a couple of months before, I’d heard the same person say “People who deserve tenure track jobs get them” at a workshop on navigating the market.

I kept thinking about how the jobs listed at graduation either didn’t pay a living wage and/or required additional training. I kept thinking about how little he clearly thought of all of us.

A lot of it, especially for recent PhDs, boils down to feeling like we hear a narrative of toxic hope until literally the moment we graduate.

It’s hard not to read it as a ploy to extract high-quality, low-wage labor, then release us into the world older, broker, and often with worse job prospects than we came in with. For those tenured profs working with grad students, that part of the job has changed, and many are not handling that reality ethically.


 

Similar Posts:

  • Sad Thursdays: The Student Perspective on Academic Hiring Practices (in Anthropological Archaeology)
  • The Professor Is In HAS Changed, Part II, or I Don’t Give a Flying Fuck What You Wear
  • How Would You Mentor Graduate Students? Another #Facepalm Fail
  • Ph.D. Poverty–Guest Post I
  • On Foregone Earnings, or the Economics of Adjunct Life (A Guest Post)

Filed Under: Academic Job Search, Advising Advice, Alt-University Critique, Mental Health and Academia, Ph.D. Poverty, Quitting--An Excellent Option

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Primary Sidebar

  • Facebook
  • RSS
  • Twitter

Buy My Book!

4.8 stars on Amazon!

The_Professor_Is_In.indd

Get Immediate Help

In addition to our blog and book, we have upcoming live webinars, pre-recorded webinars and other programs that you can get started on right away:

The Art of the Academic Cover Letter
The Art of the Article
Unstuck: The Art of Productivity
Quick Reviews
Free Productivity Webinars

Categories

  • #MeTooPhD
  • Academic Job Search
    • How To Choose and Manage Recommenders
    • How to Interview
    • How To Write Academic Job Cover Letters
    • How To Write CVs
    • Landing Your Tenure Track Job
    • Major Job Market Mistakes
    • Negotiating Offers
  • Adjunct Issues
  • Advising Advice
  • Alt-University Critique
  • Black Lives Matter
  • COVID19
  • Dispatches
  • Goodbye Ivory Towers
  • Graduate Student Concerns
    • Bad Advisors and Good Mentors
  • How To Do Conferences
  • How to Get Grants and Fellowships
  • International Perspectives
  • Intersectional Analyses
  • Makeup
  • Marginalized Voices
  • Mental Health and Academia
  • Ph.D. Poverty
  • Podcast
  • Post-Ac Free-Lancing and Small Business
  • Post-Ac Job Search
    • Careers Outside
  • Postdoc Issues
  • Productivity
    • Book Proposals and Contracts
    • Publishing Issues
    • Writing
  • Promote Yourself!
  • Quitting–An Excellent Option
  • Racism in the Academy
  • Rearview Mirror
  • Resumes & Postac Docs
  • Sexual Harassment in the Academy
  • Shame
  • Stop.Acting.Like.A.Grad.Student
  • Strategizing Your Success in Academia
  • Teaching and Research Statements
  • Teaching Demos
  • Teaching Portfolios
  • Tenure–How To Get It
    • How To Build Your Tenure File
    • Surviving Assistant Professorhood
  • The Campus Visit
  • Unstuck
  • Webinars
  • What Not To Wear
  • Women of Color in Academia
  • Work/Life Balance in Academia
  • Yes, You Can: Women in Academia
  • Your Second and Third Jobs

Footer

About Us

  • Who Is Dr. Karen?
  • Who Is On the TPII Team?
  • In The News
  • Contact Me
  • FAQs
    • Why Trust Me?
  • Testimonials

Community

  • #MeTooPhD
  • Peer Editing
  • PhD Debt Survey
  • Support Fund
  • I Help With Custody Cases for Academics

Copyright © 2023 The Professor Is In·